Irresistible Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels: Chewy, Flavorful, and Made with Freshly Milled Flour
Prepare to elevate your bagel game with these incredibly chewy and flavorful Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels, crafted with the unparalleled goodness of freshly milled flour! This recipe is a true masterpiece, loaded with the savory depth of bacon, the sharp tang of cheddar cheese, and just the right amount of kick from fresh jalapeño pieces. Designed to be perfectly balanced, these bagels offer a delightful warmth without being overly spicy, making them the most wholesome and delicious choice for your ham sandwiches, breakfast spreads, or even as a standalone savory treat. We’re confident that even the pickiest eaters and the youngest members of your family will rave about their incredible taste. Follow our comprehensive, step-by-step tutorial to easily bring these artisanal delights to your own kitchen!
Why These Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels Are a Must-Try
Whole Wheat Sourdough Bagels are a classic favorite, especially when toasted and generously smeared with creamy probiotic cream cheese. However, this Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel recipe takes that experience to an entirely new level of deliciousness. The unique combination of flavors and textures sets it apart, transforming a simple bagel into an extraordinary culinary delight.
While you can certainly infuse a regular sourdough bread loaf with cheddar cheese and jalapeño slices, the magic of an individual bagel lies in its distinctive chewiness and crisp crust. Each Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagel boasts a satisfyingly crisp exterior that gives way to a dense, incredibly chewy interior – a texture profile that simply isn’t achievable with a standard artisan bread slice. This makes every bite an experience in contrasts, far superior for holding up to your favorite fillings.
The addition of crispy, savory bacon is truly a game-changer for these sourdough bagels. It imparts a smoky depth and an irresistible textural element that complements the sharp cheddar and zesty jalapeños perfectly. With an abundant harvest of hot peppers from our garden this year, creating these flavorful cheddar jalapeño bagels felt like the most appropriate and delicious way to celebrate our bounty. It’s a taste of the garden, elevated by wholesome ingredients.
For the best results, we highly recommend using fresh jalapeño peppers, although pickled ones can work in a pinch (just be sure to drain them thoroughly to avoid excess acidity in your dough). However, one ingredient you absolutely shouldn’t skimp on is the fresh, thick-cut bacon. The rendered bacon grease, incorporated directly into the dough, is essential. It contributes an unparalleled crispness and a rich, smoky flavor that simply cannot be replicated by pre-cooked bacon bits. This fat enriches the dough, creating a truly superior homemade bagel experience.
At our farmhouse, we love to keep our sandwich options fresh and exciting, so making these sourdough bagels offers a delightful change from our usual whole-wheat hamburger buns. These bagels become the star of any meal!
I find myself constantly craving these particular bagels for my ham sandwiches, and the joy is shared by my entire family. They’re perfect for stuffing with a variety of fresh veggies, your favorite deli meats, or even a fried egg for a quick and satisfying lunch. Alternatively, serve them warm as individual, hearty breads alongside a comforting bowl of soup. For an extra special touch, slice them open, toast them, and spread with a generous dollop of cream cheese, transforming them into a bagel version of “jalapeño poppers” – utterly divine!
Effortless Baking: Fitting Sourdough Bagels into Your Busy Life
If the idea of baking bagels from scratch conjures up images of an arduous, time-consuming kitchen project, I’m here to completely change your perspective! Making these incredibly delicious and healthy sourdough bagels is surprisingly easy and fits seamlessly into even the busiest schedules. Trust me, it’s far less daunting than you might imagine.
Despite juggling homeschooling, maintaining a bustling blog, and managing all the daily mundane tasks, I regularly prepare these bagels with less than 30 minutes of total preparation time – and only about 5 minutes of actual hands-on work! The secret lies in letting your trusty stand mixer do the heavy lifting for kneading, followed by a flexible fermentation process. Typically, I let the dough ferment, then tuck it away in the fridge overnight. This means by the next day, right in time for lunch or breakfast, warm, fresh bagels are ready to be boiled and baked. It’s a schedule that truly works for real life.
The time investment is minimal, but the rewards are immense. Every minute spent is truly worth it, especially when I see the pure delight on my kids’ faces! And nothing, absolutely nothing, compares to that incredible aroma filling the house: a harmonious blend of sweet and spicy jalapeño peppers, smoky bacon, and rich cheddar cheese, all contained within one perfect bite. These flavorful sourdough bagels, made with 100% freshly milled wheat, are not just a treat for the palate but a source of genuine joy for me as a baker and a mom.
So, how do I achieve this fresh bakery quality with such ease? My typical schedule looks like this: I feed my sourdough starter early in the morning to ensure it’s robust and active. Around noon, I prepare the sourdough bagel dough. Milling my grain takes mere seconds with my efficient electric grain mill. After mixing, the dough undergoes a bulk fermentation at room temperature for about 4 hours. Following this, it goes into the fridge for a cold fermentation overnight. This entire process involves very little hands-on effort, yet it allows my family to wake up to and enjoy warm, fresh, and incredibly wholesome bagels that taste like they came straight from a gourmet bakery!
Essential Ingredients for Your Perfect Bagels
Crafting exceptional Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels begins with selecting high-quality ingredients. Each component plays a crucial role in achieving the desired flavor, texture, and nutritional value.
- Sourdough Starter: The foundation of these bagels is a vibrant, active sourdough starter. Ensure your starter is fed, bubbly, and at its peak activity. A healthy starter is paramount; it’s what provides the necessary leavening, contributing to the fantastic rise, the signature chewy texture, and the characteristic tangy flavor that makes sourdough so special. A weak starter will result in dense, flat bagels, so don’t skimp on this crucial step.
- Freshly Milled Dough: These sourdough bagels stand out for their health benefits, as they are made with 100% whole grains. I exclusively use hard white wheat berries, which I weigh precisely on a scale before milling them fresh using my grain mill. This quick process yields flour that retains all its nutrients and fresh flavor. While the grain is milling, I concurrently prepare the other ingredients, including frying the bacon, which only takes a few minutes. This simultaneous prep helps streamline the baking process.
- Jalapeños: For this recipe, I prefer using fresh jalapeños, ideally from my own garden, for their vibrant flavor and crisp texture. Fresh peppers also give you the flexibility to control the heat level; you can remove more seeds and membranes for a milder bagel, or leave them in for extra spice. While pickled jalapeños can be used as an alternative, be aware that their acidity will lend a different flavor profile, and they must be thoroughly drained to prevent excess liquid from affecting your dough’s consistency.
- Cheddar Cheese: To achieve that perfect cheesy flavor and texture, I always opt for a block of sharp cheddar cheese and shred it myself using a box grater with large holes. Freshly shredded cheese melts beautifully and integrates much better into the dough than pre-shredded varieties, which often contain anti-caking agents. The cheddar is incorporated directly into the dough and also sprinkled on top of the bagels before baking, creating a delicious, crispy cheese crust and an appealing golden appearance.
- Thick-cut Bacon: The bacon is more than just a flavor enhancer; it’s an essential textural and aromatic component. I fry two slices of thick-cut, chopped bacon in a skillet until they are deliciously brown and crisp. Once cooked, the bacon pieces and all the rendered grease are transferred to a bowl and allowed to cool completely. It’s crucial that the bacon and its grease are not hot when added to the dough, as high temperatures can inadvertently kill your sourdough starter, inhibiting its leavening power. The bacon fat is key to the bagels’ superior crispness and rich, savory flavor.
Choosing the Right Grains for Your Sourdough Bagels
One of the most common questions bakers have when working with freshly milled flour is about grain varieties. The good news is, you absolutely can experiment with different grains for your bagels! Any hard wheat variety is ideal for making perfect, chewy bagels. The robust gluten structure inherent in hard wheat is crucial for developing that desirable elasticity and chewiness that defines a great bagel.
Feel free to mix and match any hard wheat variety you prefer. For instance, you could use hard red wheat, which often imparts a slightly nuttier, more intense flavor, alongside hard white wheat. Hard white wheat is an excellent starting point for many, as it’s known for its mild flavor profile, making it quite similar in taste to conventional all-purpose flour, yet it brings all the nutritional benefits of whole grain. If you’re tempted to incorporate a low-gluten grain, such as soft white wheat, into your recipe, proceed with caution and only add a small amount. To compensate for the reduced gluten content and ensure your dough remains adequately stretchy and manageable, you may need to supplement it with a little extra vital wheat gluten. This adjustment will help maintain the structural integrity necessary for a truly chewy bagel.
Tools for Success: Recommended Baking Equipment
Having the right tools can make all the difference in your sourdough bagel baking journey, especially when working with freshly milled flour. These pieces of equipment are not just convenient; they contribute to the accuracy and efficiency of your process, ensuring fantastic results every time.
- Electric Grain Mill: An electric grain mill is truly a game-changer for homemade bread and bagel making. It allows you to transform whole wheat berries into fresh, nutrient-rich flour in mere seconds. The immediate milling preserves the delicate oils and full spectrum of nutrients that are often lost in commercially processed flours, contributing to a superior flavor and healthier product.
- Kitchen Scale: Precision is key in baking, particularly with sourdough and freshly milled flour, which can absorb liquids differently. I cannot stress enough the importance of measuring your ingredients, especially flour, with a reliable kitchen scale. Using grams will consistently give you the most accurate and reproducible results, preventing issues with dough consistency that can arise from volumetric measurements.
- Heavy-Duty Stand Mixer: Working with freshly milled whole wheat flour, especially for a dense, chewy dough like bagels, requires significant kneading to develop the gluten. This process can take longer and be more strenuous than with all-purpose flour. A heavy-duty stand mixer with a dough hook is an invaluable tool that handles the intense kneading effortlessly, saving you from a significant arm workout and ensuring proper gluten development for that perfect bagel chew.
- Glass Bowl with Lid: A simple yet essential item, a glass bowl with a lid provides the ideal environment for your dough during its fermentation process. The lid helps maintain a consistent humidity level, preventing the dough from drying out, while the glass allows you to easily observe the dough’s rise and activity without disturbing it.
- Pastry Mat: A non-stick pastry mat or silicone baking mat is incredibly helpful during the shaping stage. It provides a clean, non-stick surface to work your dough, eliminating the need to constantly flour your countertop and making the process much cleaner and more manageable.
- Large Pot and Slotted Spoon: For boiling your bagels.
- Silicone-Lined Baking Sheet: For baking the bagels to prevent sticking.
Your Step-by-Step Guide to Baking Perfect Bagels
Creating these delightful Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels might seem intricate, but breaking it down into manageable steps reveals just how accessible and enjoyable the process is. Follow these instructions carefully, and you’ll be rewarded with a batch of bakery-quality bagels right in your own kitchen.
- Mix The Sourdough Bagel Dough: Begin by combining the warm water, active sourdough starter, diced fresh jalapeños, chopped and cooled thick-cut bacon pieces (including all that flavorful bacon grease!), shredded cheddar cheese, a touch of honey, and your freshly milled flour in the bowl of your heavy-duty stand mixer. Attach the dough hook and knead the mixture for a substantial 15-20 minutes. This extended kneading is crucial for freshly milled whole wheat flour, as it helps develop the robust gluten structure necessary for truly chewy bagels. The dough should become smooth, elastic, and eventually pull away cleanly from the sides of the bowl. Once this consistency is achieved, add the sea salt and continue kneading for an additional 5 minutes. The total kneading time of approximately 25 minutes ensures optimal gluten development.
- Fermenting the Dough: Carefully transfer your well-kneaded dough into a clean glass bowl with a lid. Allow the dough to undergo its bulk fermentation at room temperature for about 4 hours. During this time, the sourdough starter will begin its magic, creating gases that leaven the dough and develop complex flavors. While I sometimes perform a few sets of stretch and folds during this period to further strengthen the gluten, they are entirely optional for this recipe due to the extended kneading. The dough’s gluten structure is already well-developed, so you can achieve amazing results without this extra step. After 4 hours, the dough should appear sticky but feel smooth and notably stretchy.
- Refrigerate for Cold Fermentation: At this point, you have the option to bake your bagels on the same day if you prefer (see notes below for same-day baking instructions). However, for enhanced flavor development, improved digestibility, and the utmost convenience, I highly recommend refrigerating the dough. This cold fermentation period, lasting 12-24 hours, allows the lactic acid bacteria in the sourdough to work slowly, deepening the flavors and making the nutrients in the whole grains more bioavailable. It also breaks up your baking schedule, making it easier to fit into a busy day.
- Shaping Your Bagels: When you’re ready to bake, remove the dough from the fridge. Place it onto a lightly cornmeal-dusted pastry mat or a lightly floured surface (the pastry mat makes working with the sticky dough much easier and reduces the need for extra flour). Divide the dough into seven equal pieces, each weighing approximately 4 ounces for consistency. Roll each piece into a smooth ball. Then, gently flatten each ball slightly and, using your finger or thumb, poke a hole directly through the center. Gently stretch this hole a bit to widen it, creating the classic bagel shape. Arrange the shaped bagels on a tray generously dusted with cornmeal to prevent sticking, and let them rest and rise for 30 minutes at room temperature.
- Boil the Bagels: While your bagels are resting, preheat your oven to 400°F (200°C). Meanwhile, fill a large pot with 3-4 quarts of water and bring it to a rolling boil. Once boiling, add 1 tablespoon each of baking soda and brown sugar to the water. These ingredients are crucial: the baking soda helps to create a beautiful, glossy, and slightly crisp crust, while the brown sugar adds a subtle sweetness and promotes browning. Carefully drop the bagels into the boiling water, submerging them completely. Boil for 30-40 seconds on one side, then flip them over with a slotted spoon and boil for another 30-40 seconds on the other side. This short boil is what gives bagels their characteristic chewiness. Remove the boiled bagels with the slotted spoon, allowing excess water to drain, and transfer them to a silicone-lined baking sheet, leaving some space between each bagel.
- Bake to Golden Perfection: Immediately after boiling and placing them on the baking sheet, sprinkle the tops of each bagel with additional shredded cheddar cheese and a few thinly sliced jalapeño pieces. Be mindful not to overload them, aiming for a pleasant distribution. Transfer the baking sheet to your preheated oven and bake for 20-22 minutes, or until the bagels are beautifully golden brown and the cheese on top is melted and slightly crispy. Let them cool slightly before slicing and enjoying the fruits of your labor!
FAQs: Your Sourdough Bagel Questions Answered
Many home bakers have questions about specific aspects of sourdough bagel making. Here are some of the most common inquiries, answered to help you achieve success.
Can Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels Be Baked The Same Day?
Yes, these delicious sourdough bagels can absolutely be made and baked on the same day! However, for optimal flavor development and the best texture, it’s generally recommended that they are baked no longer than 7 hours after you initially prepare the dough if you’re keeping it at room temperature. For same-day baking, aim for a bulk fermentation of 5-7 hours on the counter in a warm spot, then proceed with shaping, boiling, and baking as directed. If you desire the benefits of longer fermentation—such as a deeper, more complex sourdough flavor and increased bioavailability of nutrients in the grains—I highly recommend the overnight cold proofing method. I typically allow the dough to undergo a 4-hour bulk ferment at room temperature before transferring it to the fridge to ferment slowly overnight. This extended cold fermentation allows lactic acid to develop, yielding a more nuanced flavor profile and a healthier bagel. So, if you’re seeking that extra depth and goodness, let it chill in the fridge overnight!
How To Store and Freeze Sourdough Bagels Made With Jalapeños, Cheddar, and Bacon.
Proper storage is key to keeping your homemade jalapeño cheddar sourdough bagels fresh and delicious. For short-term storage, I recommend keeping your bagels in a plastic bread bag or a sealed Ziploc bag at room temperature. Alternatively, you can store them covered with the dome of a cake stand, which also helps to maintain freshness. It’s generally not recommended to store sourdough bread or bagels in the refrigerator, as the cool temperatures can cause them to become stiff and stale much faster than at room temperature.
For longer preservation, these bagels freeze exceptionally well. You can freeze them whole in a gallon freezer bag or any airtight container designed for freezing. They will maintain their quality for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to enjoy them, simply thaw the bagels entirely at room temperature before slicing and toasting them. A quick toast will bring back their wonderful texture and warmth, making them taste almost as good as fresh out of the oven.
Expert Tips for the Best Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Bagels
- Allow Dough to Acclimate: If you’ve refrigerated your dough overnight, it’s beneficial to allow it to sit at room temperature for about two hours before you begin shaping. This gentle warm-up makes the dough more pliable and easier to work with. Following shaping, let the bagels rest for another 30 minutes before boiling. While this extra rising time contributes to a lighter crumb, if you’re pressed for time, skipping this final rest won’t compromise the deliciousness of your bagels significantly.
- Ensure an Active Starter: The success of your sourdough bagels hinges on a vigorous, active starter. Plan your baking schedule to ensure your starter is fed and bubbly before you begin mixing the dough. For example, feed your starter in the early morning (around 6:00 AM) to prepare the bagel dough around noon, ensuring it’s at its peak activity for optimal rise and flavor.
- Avoid Over-Fermentation at Room Temperature: While sourdough loves fermentation, there’s a limit, especially at warmer room temperatures. Long-fermented sourdough bagels are best when the extended fermentation happens in the fridge. If the dough sits on the counter for too long (generally past 8 hours after the initial bulk ferment), it can over-ferment. This often results in the dough releasing a liquid called lactic acid, making it overly sticky, difficult to handle, and potentially giving the bagels an unpleasantly sour flavor.
- Strengthen Your Starter: The type of flour you feed your starter matters! I find that feeding my sourdough starter with unbleached bread flour, such as King Arthur, significantly strengthens it. Stronger flour means more robust gluten development in your starter, leading to more active and reliable leavening for your bagel dough.
- Embrace a Wetter Dough: Unlike traditional stiff bagel doughs, this recipe yields a slightly wetter consistency. Don’t be alarmed by this! This higher hydration is intentional, as it contributes to the exceptionally soft and uniquely chewy texture of these whole wheat sourdough bagels. It’s a key factor in their irresistible mouthfeel.
- Drain Pickled Jalapeños Thoroughly: If you opt to use pickled jalapeño peppers instead of fresh ones, it’s absolutely crucial to drain them very well. The brine is acidic and can introduce excess liquid into your dough, altering its hydration balance and potentially affecting the starter’s activity. Pat them dry with a paper towel if necessary.
- Use Fresh, Thick-Cut Bacon: For the ultimate flavor and texture, always use fresh, thick-cut bacon, not pre-cooked bacon bits. The process of frying fresh bacon yields a savory, smoky fat (bacon grease) that is incorporated directly into the dough. This grease is vital for adding incredible flavor and contributing to the superior crispness of the finished bagels. Bacon bits simply cannot replicate this depth and richness.
- Garnish with Intention: When adding the final sprinkle of cheddar cheese and jalapeño slices to the tops of your bagels before baking, aim for a light and balanced approach. You don’t want to overdo it, as too much cheese can run off or burn, and too many jalapeños can overpower the other flavors. I often cut my jalapeño slices in half to create a more even distribution and a less overwhelming aesthetic.
- Strategy for Same-Day Bagels: If you prefer to bake your sourdough bagels on the same day rather than with an overnight cold proof, plan accordingly. Begin mixing your dough in the morning to allow sufficient time for bulk fermentation (5-7 hours at room temperature). This head start will allow you to shape, boil, and bake your bagels in the evening, ensuring you can enjoy warm, fresh sourdough bagels within a single day.
EASY Sourdough Bread Recipes Using all Freshly Milled Flour:
We absolutely adore our homemade breads made with 100% freshly milled flour! Not only are they incredibly wholesome and nutritious, but they also boast an unmatched depth of flavor and aroma. If you’ve enjoyed making these bagels, or are simply looking to expand your whole-grain baking repertoire, here are some other simple and utterly delicious sourdough recipes using whole grains that you must try:
-
Whole Wheat Sourdough Bagels with Freshly Milled Flour
-
Sourdough English Muffins
-
Whole Wheat Sourdough Sandwich Bread with Freshly Milled Flour
-
Sourdough Biscuits with Freshly Milled Flour
Rate
Pin
Jalapeno Cheddar Sourdough Bagels with Freshly Milled Flour
Equipment
-
1 heavy-duty stand mixer
-
1 glass bowl with a lid
-
1 18×13″ sheet pan
-
1 silicon mat
Ingredients
Ingredients:
-
2/3 cup warm water
-
1 cup active sourdough starter
-
1 tsp honey
-
289 grams hard white wheat (freshly milled in a grain mill)
-
2 Tbsp fresh jalapenos (or pickled, just drain)
-
2 slices thick-cut bacon (chopped and fried; transfer and cool with the grease)
-
1/4 cup cheddar cheese (shredded)
-
3/4 tsp sea salt
For Boiling The Bagels:
-
3 quarts water
-
1 Tbsp brown sugar
-
1 Tbsp baking soda
Topping:
-
1 small jalapeno pepper (sliced into pieces)
-
1/3 cup cheddar cheese (shredded)
Instructions
Directions:
-
Add the water, sourdough starter, honey, freshly milled flour, chopped jalapenos, 1/4 cup cheddar cheese, and bacon with the grease to a stand mixer. Knead for 15-20 minutes until the dough is smooth and no longer sticks to the sides. Add the salt and continue to knead for five more minutes. -
Transfer to a glass bowl and cover with a lid. Ferment dough for 4 hours at room tempertature and then place bowl into the fridge to cold ferment 12-24 hours. See notes below on how to make same-day bagels. -
Shape the bagels by dividing the dough into seven equal pieces. Form each piece into a ball and poke a hole through the middle to make a bagel. -
Place bagels on a cornmeal-dusted tray and let them rise for 30 minutes. -
Meanwhile, preheat the oven to 400°F. Bring the water to a boil and add the baking soda and brown sugar. Drop the bagels in, four at a time, and flip over to each side for 30-40 seconds. Transfer them to a silicone-lined baking sheet. -
Sprinkle the tops with 1 Tbsp of cheddar cheese and a few jalapeno pieces. -
Bake the bagels for 20-22 minutes or until golden brown.
Notes
- For same-day bagels, make the dough and ferment it for 5-7 hours on the counter in a warm place. Shape and boil, then bake as directed.
- Weigh the hard white wheat berries using a scale, then run them through a grain mill to make whole wheat flour.
Nutrition per serving